Here's Why the Seattle SuperSonics Are Years Away from Being Granted Another NBA Franchise

When might the Sonics return to Seattle? Would you believe 2025?
| FROM THE PRINT EDITION |
 
 
  • Seattle SuperSonics
KEY CONCERN. The Seattle SuperSonics won this game against the Dallas Mavericks at KeyArena in April 2008. The date of the Sonics' next appearance is anyone's guess.

This article appears in print in the January 2019 issue. Click here for a free subscription.

The scene at KeyArena for the final game played in the former home of the Seattle SuperSonics before the arena’s two-year, $700 million reclamation project confirmed what most sports fans in Seattle already knew: The city deserves an NBA team.

The October 5 preseason game brought former Sonic Kevin Durant back to the place where he played his first NBA season a decade earlier. He returned as a member of the Golden State Warriors, the reigning league champion, who played the Sacramento Kings, a team that came close to relocating to Seattle a few years ago.

“Everybody in the basketball world and the NBA knows the Sonics need to be back in Seattle,” Durant said during the week leading up to the game. As if to buttress his argument, the sleeping giant that is the Sonics fan base awoke in full force. As well, legends from both the team’s storied past and the city’s wealth of home-grown talent led the way in letting the NBA’s front office know Seattle is more than ready for NBA basketball to return.

But, realistically, how could that happen? While the way seems clear for Seattle to land a National Hockey League expansion franchise in two years, what is the real path forward for the new Seattle Sonics to begin playing games in the next incarnation of the arena at Seattle Center?

The two ways the Sonics could return are via relocation and expansion, but prospects for relocation have greatly diminished in recent years. The Sacramento Kings came tantalizingly close to moving here in 2013. The Milwaukee Bucks also loomed as a relocation candidate — Steve Ballmer, now the owner of the Los Angeles Clippers, told Bill Simmons of The Ringer that he offered to buy the Bucks and move them to Seattle when the franchise was up for sale in 2014 — but former owner Herb Kohl stipulated that any group buying the team had to keep it in Milwaukee. Both teams now have new arenas.

Other possible candidates for relocation — the Memphis Grizzlies, Minnesota Timberwolves and Charlotte Hornets — were rendered unlikely by upgrades to their respective arenas.

The only real relocation candidate in the NBA now is the league’s lowest-valued franchise — at $1 billion — the New Orleans Pelicans. Former Pelicans owner Tom Benson, also the owner of the New Orleans Saints, died last March. His widow, Gayle Benson, is now in charge of the team, which in 2012 signed a deal for a publicly funded renovation of their arena, currently known as the Smoothie King Center, which would keep the team in New Orleans until 2024.

A decade after the Sonics left Seattle for Oklahoma City, the NBA has learned that relocations can get ugly and the league has aggressively worked to stop teams from moving. The league prevented former Pelicans owner George Shinn from moving in the wake of Hurricane Katrina and subsequently bought the franchise from him before selling it to Benson in 2012. It seems unlikely the NBA would look favorably upon a move by the Pelicans, even though New Orleans is the 51st-largest media market in the United States and Seattle-Tacoma has risen to No. 12. So, while a relocation of the Pelicans can’t be ruled out entirely, if it were to happen, even an optimistic timeline wouldn’t bring a team to Seattle until the mid-2020s.

This leaves expansion as the likeliest route to landing a team. As a brand, the NBA is thriving, generating $7.4 billion in revenue last year, up 25 percent from the previous season, according to Forbes. The 30-team league has also conquered social media unlike any other sport. The talent level is at a high-water mark, and one could argue that the league is readier now to bring on two more franchises than at any point in its history.

But Commissioner Adam Silver has not entertained the idea, going as far as to say plainly during a press event during the playoffs last year, “Expansion is not on our agenda right now.”

In an August 2018 ESPN report on expansion in American professional sports leagues, reporter Brian Windhorst also threw some cold water on Seattle’s aspirations for a new Sonics team, saying the KeyArena renovation isn’t viewed quite as favorably by the NBA as it might be in Seattle and that the league could have expansion to Mexico City higher on its priority list.

There may be some truth in that assessment, but it makes sense for the NBA to take a position on the renovation, which is being done in anticipation of an NHL team but is also designed for an NBA club. As it does with any other arena, the NBA is going to want to have a say in how its product is presented, and it stands to reason the league would benefit by using its position on the arena as a bargaining chip to get what it’s looking for when the time comes to discuss expansion in a realistic context.

So, when would that discussion occur?

The earliest time, though an unlikely one, would be 2022. The league is considering abolishing its “one-and-done” rule that requires potential players to spend at least one year in college. Many top-notch high school players could declare themselves eligible for the draft that year, dramatically expanding the talent pool and possibly providing sufficient impetus for expansion.

A more likely scenario, however, is that expansion will not occur until after the 2024-25 season, when the NBA’s nine-year, $24 billion television and media rights deal with ESPN and Turner Sports is scheduled to expire. Asking 30 ownership groups to accept smaller slices of the revenue pie before they have an opportunity to renegotiate the TV deal seems completely unfathomable.

So, basketball-starved fans might end up waiting close to 20 years until they can cheer on their team once again. Bear in mind that since 2000, seven professional franchises — one in baseball, one in hockey, two in football and three in basketball — have relocated. Only one of the spurned cities — Charlotte, North Carolina — has regained a team.

Of course, Seattle deserves an NBA team. That Friday night game in October left no doubt. But, barring a miracle, Seattle is going to have to wait several more years. We can only hope the experience doesn’t become the sporting equivalent of Waiting for Godot.

How Long Does It Take?
By John Levesque

Seattle has been waiting 11 years for a new NBA team. It waited seven years between losing the Pilots baseball team and welcoming the Mariners. Here’s a look at how long other cities have waited after losing professional sports teams. The new teams’ names are in parentheses. Entries in italics indicate an existing team moved from another city. Entries in roman type indicate the city acquired an expansion franchise. 

1955: Milwaukee Hawks (NBA) move to St. Louis. Milwaukee waits 13 years (Milwaukee Bucks).

1958: Brooklyn Dodgers and San Francisco Giants (MLB) move to Los Angeles and San Francisco, respectively. New York City waits 4 years (New York Mets).

1960: Minneapolis Lakers (NBA) move to Los Angeles. Minneapolis waits 29 years (Minnesota Timberwolves).

1962: Philadelphia Warriors (NBA) move to San Francisco. Philadelphia waits 1 year (Philadelphia 76ers, formerly Syracuse Nationals).

1963: Chicago Zephyrs (NBA) move to Baltimore. Chicago waits 3 years (Chicago Bulls).

1966: Milwaukee Braves (MLB) move to Atlanta. Milwaukee waits 4 years (Milwaukee Brewers, formerly Seattle Pilots).

1968: Kansas City Athletics (MLB) move to Oakland. Kansas City waits 1 year (Kansas City Royals).

1970: Seattle Pilots (MLB) move to Milwaukee. Seattle waits 7 years (Seattle Mariners).

1972: Washington Senators (MLB) move to Arlington, Texas. Washington, D.C., waits 34 years (Washington Nationals, formerly Montreal Expos).

1971: San Diego Rockets (NBA) move to Houson. San Diego waits 7 years (San Diego Clippers, formerly Buffalo Braves).

1979: New Orleans Jazz (NBA) move to Salt Lake City. New Orleans waits 23 years (New Orleans Hornets, now Pelicans).

1980: Atlanta Flames (NHL) move to Calgary. Atlanta waits 19 years (Atlanta Thrashers).

1982: Colorado Rockies (NHL) move to New Jersey. Colorado waits 13 years (Colorado Avalanche, formerly Quebec Nordiques).

1984: Baltimore Colts (NFL) move to Indianapolis. Baltimore waits 12 years (Baltimore Ravens, formerly Cleveland Browns).

1987: St. Louis Cardinals (NFL) move to Phoenix. St. Louis waits 8 years (St. Louis Rams, formerly Los Angeles Rams).

1993: Minnesota North Stars (NHL) move to Dallas. Minnesota waits 4 years (Minnesota Wild).

1995: Los Angeles Rams (NFL) move to St. Louis and Los Angeles Raiders (NFL) move to Oakland. Los Angeles waits
20 years (Los Angeles Rams, formerly St. Louis Rams).

1996: Winnipeg Jets (NHL) move to Phoenix. Winnipeg waits 15 years (Winnipeg Jets, formerly Atlanta Thrashers).

1996: Cleveland Browns (NFL) move to Baltimore. Cleveland waits 3 years (Cleveland Browns).

1997: Houston Oilers (NFL) move to Memphis/Nashville. Houston waits 5 years (Houston Texans).

2002: Charlotte Hornets (NBA) move to New Orleans. Charlotte waits 2 years (Charlotte Bobcats, now Hornets).

2006: San Jose Earthquakes (MLS) relocate to Houston. San Jose waits 2 years (San Jose Earthquakes).

KEY: NBA = National Basketball Association; MLB = Major League Baseball; NHL = National Hockey League; NFL = National Football League; MLS = Major League Soccer